09:21 pm: Tired of being silent...
Apologies in advance for not knowing how to LJ cut.
Well, I've mostly been silent on the group of churches leaving the Vineyard over the women in leadership issue. I'm really sick of being quiet, which I suppose is why I have a blog(not that I use it alot). A little background. I went to college at SIU. Most of you know that. All but 1 of the pastors whose churches left shaped my life in a significant way, and I wouldn't be anywhere near where I am without them. I love these guys. Steve Morgan is still the best communicator I've ever heard and he follows God with extraordinary faith. Sandor Paull found places for me to serve and just loved me while I was rebelling against God in college. He has an extremely steady personality for a person who is radically following Jesus. This probably makes me identify more with him than any of these guys. Ben Powers pushed me to pursue charismatic gifts more and gave me a prophetic word that in part led to me pursuing full time ministry as a long term endeavour. Jeff Miller left at about the same time I showed up in C-dale.
I found out about the possibility of the churches leaving in late July while on a missions trip. I was in shock. Then I was angry. Then I tried to understand. Then I was angry again. My theology on this is really simple. Jesus created the church. God gifted the people of the church. The job of church leadership is to use the gifts of its people to bring the Kingdom of God as it has been called. You could argue that I am just ignoring gender altogether. You're right! I would argue that most arguements against women in leadership are implying things onto our culture that are different than what the original text implies. I'd argue it's placing the belif on the text, not taking if from the text. I'd say look at the person (gifts, empowerment, character, etc.), not at the gender followed by looking at the the person.
Anyways, I can deal with their difference in theology. But, I was absolutely broken over their leaving the movement because local churches are allowed to decide whether to ordain women or not. Part of the beauty of the Vineyard is the ability of local churches to hold varying non-central beliefs and be part of the same movement. It's extremely frustrating to me that the decision of the national board would have exactly zero effect on these local churches and yet the decision is made to leave this movement. That leads me to believe that the problem is on regoinal/national level for these guys. Is the thought of having Di Leman or Adey Wassink as a regional authority really too much to bear?!? Seriously.
I've heard that an explaination that was given is that it's a slippery slope from ordaining women to ordaining homosexuals. I really don't buy that arguement at all and I don't see where it would come from, aside from looking at other main-line denomonations that have gone down that road. I feel like that's a guilty until proven innocent kind of philosophy. I have to wonder if they will come back when the movement doesn't go down that road. Somehow I doubt it, although ultimately I hope that's what happens.
This of course leads to the arguement in my head(I'm not the only one that has those, right?!?) what would cause me to leave the Vineyard. Would ordaining homosexuals? To be honest, the Vineyard probably has ordained homosexual pastors. It probably hasn't know that was the case at the time. I probably would think twice about our movement if it decided to ordain openly rebelious unrepentant homosexuals.
I think that the leadership structure of our movement is extremely well set up to avoid sliding in that direction. I feel like denomonations, or sections of denomonations that have gone in that direction have become politicized which has led to their doctrinal downfall. Could polotics creep into the Vineyard. Sure, already has I'm sure. Is that what's driving the push towards women in leadership...I don't think so.
Basically this has been tough to deal with. I want to bless these guys and knock them upside the head at the same time, though it's probably not my place to do that. Enough thinking out loud for now, although this is somewhat incomplete and unformed. Deal wit it.
Current Mood: 
tired